Man Charged in Armed Robbery of NFL Player in New Jersey

Caption: New York Jets players and personnel stand for the national anthem prior to kickoff during a preseason game. Source: Wikimedia Commons / Keith Allison, CC BY-SA 2.0.

A 26-year-old man from Paterson, New Jersey, has been charged in connection with a violent armed robbery that targeted an NFL player for the New York Jets and another victim in Morristown. Prosecutors say the suspects followed the victims home and ambushed them at gunpoint in a quiet suburban neighborhood.

The charges include two counts of first-degree robbery and one count of second-degree conspiracy to commit armed robbery. Authorities describe the case as a deliberate “follow-home” attack tied to the victims’ movements earlier that night.

The indictment marks a significant step in a case that alarmed residents and renewed concerns about targeted robberies involving public figures and their families.

What Authorities Say Happened

According to Morris County officials, the robbery occurred on Feb. 15, 2025, in the Windmill Pond neighborhood of Morristown. Investigators say the victims had returned from New York City when they were confronted outside their home.

Prosecutors allege that at least one suspect was armed and demanded money and valuables. Personal property and cash were taken before the suspects fled the scene.

No serious physical injuries were reported, but authorities said the encounter was traumatic. The use of a firearm elevated the charges to the most serious robbery counts under New Jersey law.

Victims and Community Impact

The victims included a New York Jets player and another individual believed to be close to him. Officials have not publicly identified either victim, citing safety and privacy concerns.

Neighbors described the area as typically quiet, making the crime particularly unsettling. For many residents, the idea that someone could be followed home and robbed at gunpoint struck at a sense of everyday security.

Law enforcement officials emphasized that while the victim’s professional status drew attention, the crime reflects a broader pattern of follow-home robberies that can affect anyone. They urged the public to remain vigilant and report suspicious behavior.

Investigation and Evidence

Authorities say the investigation relied heavily on electronic and digital evidence. Surveillance footage, cellphone data, and other records were used to connect the suspect to the robbery.

Prosecutors allege that the defendant played a coordinating role, supporting the conspiracy charge. Court documents indicate investigators tracked movements before and after the robbery to establish involvement.

At the time of the indictment, the defendant was already being held on unrelated charges. Officials said that custody status helped ensure he would remain detained as the robbery case moved forward.

What Comes Next in Court

The defendant is scheduled to appear in Morris County Superior Court, where he will be formally arraigned on the charges. If convicted, first-degree robbery carries the potential for decades in state prison.

Prosecutors have not said whether additional suspects will be charged, noting that the investigation remains active. Defense attorneys have not yet publicly commented on the allegations.

For the community and the victims, the filing of charges represents a measure of accountability. Authorities say the case underscores the seriousness with which New Jersey treats armed robberies, particularly those involving coordinated planning and firearms.

References: ABC News | nbcnewyork.com | AP News